Traditional vs. Modern Architecture: Which Do Buyers Prefer?

In recent years, there’s been a noticeable trend toward more traditional architecture when building custom homes. In fact, according to a 2024 survey by the National Association of Home Builders, only 14% of people across the country prefer a modern home, less than half the number looking for more traditional styles. This shift reflects a return to what is familiar, acknowledging a desire for comfort, stability, and neighborhood connections.

Modern Architecture or Traditional Design? Aspects to Consider

Nostalgia and Tradition: One of the most significant factors driving the trend away from modern architecture is based in nostalgia. Many Floridians cherish the architectural styles that characterize the state’s rich history, whether Spanish Mission-style or mid-century. These styles fill local communities and resonate with residents, representing a tangible connection to the area’s past. For many, traditional architecture represents a lifestyle that emphasizes warmth and familiarity. In contrast to the sleek lines and stark minimalism of modern design, traditional homes often feature intricate details, inviting porches, and cozy interiors that evoke a sense of family and belonging. This emotional pull is especially strong among those who have lived in Florida for generations, as these architectural styles are intertwined with personal memories and neighborhood identity.

Environmental Considerations and Materials: Traditional homes often incorporate materials and designs better suited to the local climate, promoting energy efficiency. For example, homes designed in the Mediterranean Revival style typically feature thick stucco walls and tile roofs that help regulate indoor temperatures, reducing the reliance on air conditioning.

Modern homes, with their extensive use of glass, may not provide as much protection against Florida’s intense weather, including hurricanes and heavy rains. As climate concerns become more pressing, residents increasingly value durability and resilience in their homes. Traditional architecture embodies these qualities, with designs that have stood the test of time and proven well-suited for the local environment.

Community-Oriented Living: The move away from modern architecture also aligns with a broader cultural shift towards reconnecting with others. Like many contemporary trends, modern architectural designs often prioritize individualism, privacy, and personal space, usually at the expense of real-life connections. However, with traditional front porches and large yards, more conventional homes hint at the return of the neighborhoods many of us grew up with.

Floridians are increasingly seeking communities that promote interaction and collaboration among residents. Traditional homes are more conducive to inviting atmospheres where families can gather, children can play, and neighbors can engage with one another. This emphasis on community is especially important in a state where people move from all over the country, starting over and planting new roots.

Trends and Media: With the rise of social media platforms, many Floridians looking to build custom homes are exposed to images of picturesque, traditional homes that inspire them to pursue similar aesthetics. Popular television shows and online influencers often showcase the charm of historic homes, further cementing the desire for a more classic approach to architecture. Moreover, there’s a growing market for renovation and restoration projects that emphasize preserving the character of older homes. This trend protects and boosts property values while contributing to the cultural fabric of neighborhoods, making them more appealing to prospective buyers.

As more custom home buyers pursue classic aesthetics, traditional architectural styles are experiencing a renaissance. This shift enriches Florida’s aesthetic landscape and contributes to a more sustainable and connected way of life.

At CMSA Architects, we are dedicated to building homes that reflect the Gulf Coast’s charm, history, and stories. If you want to design a new home in Sarasota or Manatee, call the architectural team with 30 years of experience. Click to view our portfolio and get inspired!